Power of Feedback: How to Give and Receive Constructive Criticism
Unlock the power of feedback for better poetry (and give it too!)
![](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F8ac00448-5158-40f8-8c66-00c8d9669982_3456x5184.jpeg)
The Power of Feedback in Poetry's Playground
Have you ever poured your heart and soul into a poem, only to have it met with crickets? Or maybe you've shared your work with a friend and received some, well, less-than-helpful criticism? We've all been there, poets of all stripes. But what if I told you that feedback, even the kind that stings a little, can be a powerful tool for growth?
The Magic of Constructive Criticism
Constructive criticism isn't about tearing someone's work down. It's about offering honest feedback, both positive and negative, that helps the writer improve their craft. Think of it like a sculptor taking a chisel to a block of marble – chipping away at unnecessary bits to reveal the masterpiece within.
Benefits for Everyone
Here's the beauty of constructive criticism: it's a two-way street.
For the Writer: Feedback can help you identify areas for improvement in your poetry, from technical aspects like rhythm and rhyme to the overall impact on the reader. It can also give you a fresh perspective on your work, sparking new ideas and revisions.
For the Reader: By offering feedback, you become an active participant in the creative process. You help refine the poet's work, making it more impactful and engaging for future readers like yourself.
The Art of Giving Constructive Criticism
Sharing your thoughts on someone's poem can feel daunting. But fear not, fellow wordsmiths! Here are some key principles to guide you…
Focus on the Work, Not the Person
It's easy to get caught up in how the poem "makes you feel" and forget that you're critiquing the poem itself, not the poet. Separate the artist from their art. Focus your feedback on the technical elements, word choices, and overall effectiveness of the poem.
Specificity is Key
Vague comments like "it needs work" aren't helpful. Instead, pinpoint specific areas for improvement. For instance, if the poem's rhythm feels off-beat, mention a particular line that could be reworked for smoother flow.
The Feedback Sandwich
Nobody likes a criticism buffet. The "feedback sandwich" technique helps deliver constructive feedback in a palatable way.
Start with a Compliment: Acknowledge something you genuinely appreciate about the poem. Maybe it's a powerful image, a clever turn of phrase, or the overall emotional impact.
Offer Constructive Criticism: Now's the time to mention what you think could be improved. Be specific, respectful, and offer suggestions for alternatives (more on that later).
End on a Positive Note: Reaffirm your appreciation for the poem and encourage the poet to keep writing.
Offer Suggestions, Not Solutions
The goal is to guide the poet, not dictate their next move. Instead of saying "change this word to 'luminous,'" suggest synonyms or explain why the current word choice might not be working. Let the poet explore options and find the solution that resonates with their vision.
Consider Delivery
Timing and tone are crucial. Choose a private setting where the poet feels comfortable discussing their work. Be respectful, encouraging, and avoid accusatory language. Focus on "I" statements (e.g., "I found this line a bit confusing") rather than accusatory "you" statements (e.g., "This line is confusing").
Receiving Feedback Like a Pro: Mastering the Art of "Yes, And..."
So, you've bravely shared your poem and received some feedback. Now what? Here's how to approach constructive criticism with grace and a growth mindset:
Check Your Ego at the Door
The first step is to detach your ego from your work. Remember, feedback isn't a personal attack; it's an opportunity to learn. Approach the critique with an open mind and a willingness to improve.
Listen Actively
Don't get defensive! Pay close attention to the specifics of the feedback. Ask clarifying questions if something is unclear. This shows the giver you're genuinely interested in their perspective.
Don't Take it Personally
Separate constructive criticism from personal attacks. If the feedback feels harsh, take a deep breath and remember they're critiquing the work, not you.
Consider the Source
Not all feedback is created equal. Evaluate the giver's expertise and experience. Feedback from a seasoned poet in your writing group might carry more weight than a casual comment from a friend unfamiliar with poetry.
Take Time to Reflect
Don't react impulsively. Process the feedback after some time has passed. Consider which points resonate and how you can use them to improve your poem.
Embrace the "Yes, And..." Mentality
Instead of getting stuck on what "doesn't work," approach the feedback as a springboard for new ideas. Think "yes, I can see how that could be improved, and here's how I might address it..."
Putting it into Practice: Workshop Wisdom
Imagine you're in a writing group, sharing a new poem titled "Autumn's Lament." Here's how constructive criticism can play out…
The Poem
The leaves, once vibrant hues of gold,
Now lie scattered, brown and cold.
A crisp wind whispers through the trees,
A symphony of nature's sighs.
Feedback in Action
Poet: So, what do you all think?
Sarah: I really like the image of the leaves scattered on the ground. It creates a vivid picture of autumn's change.
Mark: (Using the Feedback Sandwich) This is a good start! The imagery is strong, especially the "symphony of nature's sighs." However, I found the first line a bit generic. "Vibrant hues of gold" could be more specific. Maybe mention colors like crimson or amber?
Poet: That's a good point, Mark. I could definitely explore some richer vocabulary there.
Elena: (Offering Suggestions) Perhaps you could also consider adding a sensory detail beyond sight. The crisp wind is mentioned, but what about the sound of leaves crunching underfoot, or the chill in the air?
Poet: Great suggestion, Elena! I want to capture the feeling of autumn more fully.
David: (Considering Delivery) Overall, I think this poem has a lot of potential. Maybe we can discuss some options for revising the first line after the session?
Poet: Absolutely, David. Thanks for your feedback!
Discussion Continues...
This is just a brief example, but it demonstrates how constructive criticism can be a collaborative process. By offering specific suggestions, asking questions, and maintaining a positive tone, the group members help the poet refine their work without stifling their creativity.
The Feedback Loop that Fuels Poetry's Flame
Constructive criticism isn't just about pointing out flaws; it's about fostering growth and igniting the creative spark. By giving and receiving feedback effectively, we can elevate our poetry to new heights.
Embrace the Feedback Loop
Remember, feedback is a two-way street. Actively seek critique from trusted readers and writing groups. In turn, offer thoughtful and constructive feedback to fellow poets. This creates a supportive environment where everyone can learn and improve.
Keep Exploring
The world of poetry is vast and ever-evolving. Here are some additional resources to fuel your journey:
Online Poetry Communities: Many online platforms offer critique forums and workshops specifically for poets.
Poetry Magazines and Literary Journals: Look for publications that offer feedback opportunities for submissions.
Tailoring Your Approach
There are some nuances to consider when giving feedback to poets of varying experience:
For Beginners: Focus on core elements like imagery, rhyme, and meter. Offer guidance and encouragement as they build their foundation.
For Experienced Poets: Delve deeper into aspects like voice, style, and thematic exploration. Challenge them to push creative boundaries.
Remember, the most important ingredient is passion.
By nurturing a love of language, embracing feedback, and constantly learning, you can refine your craft and share your unique voice with the world.
Bonus Section: Extra Tips for Mastering the Feedback Dance
This section can offer some concise takeaways and additional resources for readers who want to delve deeper.
Be Mindful of Tone: A sprinkle of humor or a personal anecdote can lighten the mood and make feedback more palatable.
Focus on the Positive: Even when providing critical suggestions, highlight the aspects of the poem that work well.
Celebrate Milestones: Acknowledge the poet's progress and celebrate milestones on their creative journey.
Embrace Different Styles: Remember, there's no single "right" way to write poetry. Appreciate diverse voices and approaches.
For Online Resources
Poetry Foundation
https://www.poetryfoundation.org/
Offers a wealth of resources, including articles on giving and receiving feedback, alongside a vibrant online community forum.
Critique Circle
https://www.critiquecircle.com/
A dedicated platform for writers to share their work and receive constructive feedback from peers.
If you want to leave me a tip, to help support me and Wandering Metaphors, you can do so by clicking on the button below…